After my last post, I saw a blog post on another value investing site that criticized the type of CAPE analysis that I presented last week to indicate the market was overvalued.
The author of that post suggests that the CAPE is useless for comparisons since FAS 157 changed accounting for fair value. A review of other posts recently made by the author indicate that he is fairly bullish on not just the market, but also the economy.
I am a rational optimist and I would like to be as optimistic as “valueplays”, but he is wrong to assume that the reason for the concern about market valuation is merely because of the level of the CAPE. As I have written in more detail before, and even indicated in that last post, it is the other statistics that consistently corroborate the CAPE that indicate there is not something fundamentally different about this period compared with prior periods.
Consider, for example, Tobin’s Q ratio, which measures the market’s price relative to the replacement cost of the assets for all of the companies in the market. It is higher than at any time in history bar the dot com bubble when investor psyche went overboard on “it’s different this time” thinking.
Notice that Tobin’s Q is not a straight measure of corporate book value, for which it is possible that one component–retained earnings–could be distorted by FAS 157. Tobin’s Q is an estimate of the cost to replace the assets that are already in productive use. It may not be perfect, but it corroborates the implications of the CAPE.
Consider, also, Warren Buffett’s favorite indicator of market valuation known as Buffett’s P/E given by the following ratio:
(Market capitalization) / (Nominal GDP)
Notice FAS 157 would have little influence on nominal GDP. Buffett’s P/E is more than two standard deviations higher than it’s average since 1950. Again, the only time it has been higher was during the ridiculous dot com bubble.
I have also written that the recovery has been weak based on my favorite employment statistic. But, earlier this month ”valueplays” saw “Positive Signs Everywhere“. I certainly hope he is correct, but this market looks to me like it is one misstep away from a long fall based on the above statistics and:
-
Total debt is higher than at any time in history (there was no de-leveraging);
-
Interest rates are lower and the Federal Reserve Balance Sheet is higher than any time in history. The Fed is practically out of bullets; and
-
Corporate profits–the most mean-reverting statistic in finance according to Jeremy Grantham at GMO–are as high as they have been in history;
Invest accordingly.
